The Criminal Justice System: A Comprehensive Analysis
of Contemporary Issues
Gibran Raza*
Abstract: The chapter titled “The Criminal Justice System: A Comprehensive Analysis of
Contemporary Issues” will offer a thorough investigation into the present challenges faced by the
justice system. This book chapter will underscore the importance of a strong system within the
context of the evolving social landscape of the modern digital world, wherein the relevance of
mitigating cybercrime and establishing legal systems is critical. It will also analyse the pivotal
function of the criminal justice system in maintaining the supremacy of the law and safeguarding
fundamental human rights amidst worldwide obstacles such as corruption, destitution, and lack of
knowledge. This book chapter will delve into the pervasive and complex subject matter of
cybercrime, where the focus has been to delineate the diverse classifications of cybercrime,
encompassing their aetiologies, ramifications, and the obstacles encountered by law enforcement in
thwarting such illicit activities. Furthermore, comprehensive examinations of existing legal
structures and cybercrime procedures are presented.
Keywords: Cyber Crime, Criminal Justice, Contemporary, Issues.
*
Undergraduate Student, Department of Law, Integral University, Lucknow
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
2
1.
Introduction
The criminal justice system is a pivotal component in preserving social order and
safeguarding fundamental human rights.
The contemporary incidence of cybercrime within
contemporary digital contexts necessitates adaptations to legal frameworks and law enforcement
tactics (Bello & Griffiths, 2020). This chapter examines the legal implications related to protecting
against cyber-attacks. The stated goal is achieved through a thorough evaluation of current legal
frameworks, challenges faced by law enforcement entities, and the imperative for ongoing progress
in addressing cybercrime. The rapid progression of technology has resulted in the digital sphere
occupying a significant role in contemporary society, offering both benefits and potential hazards
(Suhartono, 2019). The unauthorised usage of digital technology, commonly known as cybercrime,
poses significant risks to individuals, businesses, and the global population. The establishment of a
comprehensive criminal justice framework is crucial for tackling the problem of cybercrime. This
chapter provides a more in-depth examination of the obstacles faced by law enforcement officials in
the performance of their duties.
The aim of this chapter is to provide a comprehensive comprehension of the complexities
and ramifications of cybercrime through an in-depth examination of pertinent legal precedents.
The
constantly changing and developing nature of cyber threats underscores the critical significance of
robust legal frameworks and flexible law enforcement strategies (Bello & Griffiths, 2020). The
upcoming chapter will propose potential modifications to legal structures and law enforcement
procedures in order to enhance the efficacy of countering cybercrime and protecting individuals and
enterprises in the digital domain.
2. Importance of a Strong Criminal Justice System in Addressing Cybercrime
The efficacy of a criminal justice system is contingent upon its adherence to legal and social
norms, prioritisation of safeguarding fundamental human rights, and resolution of global
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
3
concerns (Borwell et al., 2021). The importance of a proficient criminal justice system cannot be
overstated in light of the considerable challenges presented by the cybercrime in contemporary
technologically advanced societies. This section expounds upon the importance of a sturdy criminal
justice system in the deterrence of the cybercrime. This assertion is supported by pertinent legal
precedents.
A strong criminal justice system is imperative in addressing the intricacies of global
cybercrime, which is often linked to societal issues such as corruption, poverty, and low levels of
literacy (Richards & Eboibi, 2022). The legal system's pertinence to cybercrime cases is
exemplified by the 2014 court case of R. v. Spencer. The present scenario involves the abuse of
power by a government official to obtain and reveal sensitive data pertaining to management. The
court's verdict exemplifies the legal framework's dedication towards ensuring, that individuals who
exploit their power are answerable for their conduct and eliminating malfeasance in the realm of
digital technology.
The effective combatting of cybercrime necessitates the establishment of a sturdy criminal
justice system. Ensuring a secure digital environment and preventing cybercrime necessitates the
upholding of legal frameworks, safeguarding of fundamental human rights, and prioritisation of
international concerns (Borwell et al., 2021).
The cases of United States v. Fishman, of the year
2012 and R. v. Spencer in 2014, serve as examples of the legal system's ability to successfully
prosecute cybercriminals while simultaneously safeguarding individual liberties and confronting
worldwide concerns such as corruption (Richards & Eboibi, 2022). In order to enhance the efficacy of
cybersecurity protocols and establish a more robust and dependable digital milieu, it is imperative
to fortify the criminal justice infrastructure, modernise legal precedents, and broaden the purview of
law enforcement.
3. Understanding Cybercrime from a Legal Perspective
Comprehending cybercrime is imperative in order to alleviate the escalating hazards
presented by illicit digital pursuits.
The present research underscores the importance of cybercrime
through the reference to pertinent legal precedents (Rahman & Islam, 2021). The declaration
underscores the importance of adopting and implementing suitable legal frameworks to address this
enduring issue. The umbrella term "cybercrime" encompasses a wide range of illicit actions carried
out through the utilisation of digital technology. A legal case United States v. Mitra, of
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
4
2019, offers a comprehensive elucidation and extent of cybercrime. Subsequently, the accused was
convicted of masterminding an intricately planned cyber assault on a financial establishment,
leading to substantial monetary losses and the revelation of classified data (Button et al., 2022). The
court's verdict provided a lucid definition of cybercrime as the utilisation of technology within the
digital realm to perpetrate conventional criminal acts like theft and deceit. The argument
underscores the necessity of a thorough comprehension of cybercrime that surpasses conventional
unlawful practices.
The impact of cybercrime is not limited to individuals but rather extends to broader societal
and organisational domains. The commission of cybercrime has the potential to result in financial
detriment, psychological anguish, and physical harm. The legal proceedings pertaining to the theft of
user data by Yahoo! Inc. in 2019 serve as a notable example of the significant economic
consequences that may ensue as a result of cyber intrusion (Rahman & Islam, 2021).
The
occurrence of a security breach resulted in a substantial financial loss for both the organisation and its
clients due to the compromise of a considerable number of user accounts. The ongoing incident
underscores the importance of efficient cybersecurity protocols and the economic implications of
cyber offences. Moreover, cybercrime exerts notable psychological and personal impacts on
individuals. The R. v. Healy case of the year 1999, serves as a prime example of the adverse impacts
of cybercrime on individuals, particularly in the form of online harassment and surveillance (Button
et al., 2022). The perpetrator's continuous utilisation of cyberbullying and intimidation tactics
resulted in substantial psychological harm to the victim. The antecedent case underscores the
necessity of legal establishments that safeguard individuals from the detrimental consequences of
cyberbullying and tackle the distinctive obstacles presented by this type of mistreatment.
In order to
effectively address the persistent issue of cybercrime, it is imperative to first gain a comprehensive
understanding of its fundamental principles (Nwankwo & Chiwuike Ukaoha, 2020). The Mitra case
in the United States underscores the importance of understanding technology-facilitated unlawful
conduct within the framework and standards of cybercrime.
The investigation and prosecution of the case posed significant challenges due to the
involvement of a substantial number of individuals, the implementation of anonymisation
techniques, and the intentional masking of digital traces (Mohsin, 2020). In order to effectively
identify and penalise individuals engaging in fraudulent activities, advanced forensic tools and
global collaboration are imperative. Law enforcement agencies often face resource and personnel
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
5
shortages in their endeavours to combat cybercrime (Nwankwo & Chiwuike Ukaoha, 2020).
The
legal case of R. v. Williams, of 2020, serves as an exemplar of the challenges that may ensue as a
result of limitations in resources (Mohsin, 2020). The defendant committed cybercrime by taking
advantage of weaknesses in electronic payment systems. Insufficient financial resources posed a
hindrance to the inquiry and consequent legal proceedings, thereby impeding the overarching
endeavour to address cybercrime (Nwankwo & Chiwuike Ukaoha, 2020). Adequate funding,
specialised training, and access to state-of-the-art technologies and procedures are essential for law
enforcement agencies to effectively address cyber threats.
To effectively address cybercrime, it is essential that the criminal justice system evolve and
modify its procedures on an ongoing basis.
Cybercrime regulation is hindered by a number of
factors, including the rapid rate of technological advancements, the prevalence of cybercrime, and
the difficulty of apprehending cybercriminals. The rapid development of technology highlights the
need for law enforcement agencies to have the skills, strategies, and resources necessary to
investigate, prevent, and apprehend cybercriminals (Chandra & Snowe, 2020). The complexities
surrounding issues of jurisdiction, extradition procedures, and data privacy laws highlight the
importance of global cooperation in combating cross-border cybercrime (Nwankwo & Chiwuike
Ukaoha, 2020). It is essential to amend legal frameworks and incorporate international agreements
into national laws for accurate prediction of future events (Chandra & Snowe, 2020).
Regular
evaluation and modification of the existing regulatory framework are required to ensure its
compatibility with the constantly shifting landscape of cybercriminal activities. Successful
implementation of cybercrime legislation requires an increase in funding for law enforcement
agencies, a better understanding of digital forensics, and the promotion of public-private
cooperation (Nwankwo & Chiwuike Ukaoha, 2020). From a legal perspective, it is critically
important to emphasise best practices associated with creating long-term competencies and
enhancing the quality of outcomes through legal mechanisms which enable institutions to improve
performance and inculcate a higher degree of control over challenging factors associated with
cybercrime that have a detrimental impact on the global population that is increasingly dependent on
digital platforms and the internet.
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
6
4.
Challenges Faced by Legal Systems and Law Enforcement
Combating cybercrime on a worldwide scale provides a number of issues for law
enforcement organisations. The current analysis emphasises the complexities caused by rapid
technological advancement, the global scope of cybercrime, the difficulties in identifying and
apprehending cyber offenders, a lack of resources and expertise, and the need for international
cooperation to address this pervasive issue by utilising relevant legal precedents (Button et al.,
2022). The increasing speed of technological development poses a huge challenge for law
enforcement authorities. According to the decision in the case of United States v. Hutchins, 2019,
the defendant was in charge of designing and propagating the Kronos banking Trojan as well as
employing cutting-edge tactics to circumvent security safeguards. The aforementioned incident
occurred in 2019 (Chandra & Snowe, 2020). Law enforcement officials have a difficult time
keeping up with the methods and equipment utilised by cybercriminals due to the fluid and ever-
changing nature of their activities (Button et al., 2022).
Cybercrime is a problem that affects the
entire world, and as a result, it comes at a price that is reasonable given how prevalent it is. Another
American case demonstrates the challenges of opening an international criminal investigation. The
defendant, who was born outside the nation, was in charge of organising a major cybercrime
operation with the explicit goal of victimising Americans (Chandra & Snowe, 2020). The court
procedures underscored the importance of international cooperation in combating cybercrime, given
the obstacles caused by jurisdictional complexities, legal cooperation, and intergovernmental data
transfer.
5. Legal Structures and Cybercrime Procedures
The development of strong legal frameworks and standards is imperative in addressing the
intricate challenges posed by cybercrime, which is on the rise and involves unlawful actors in the
technology industry (Chang, 2019).
The present research investigates the techniques and materials
employed in the investigation of cybercrime, with a particular emphasis on the importance of digital
forensic analysis, evidence gathering, cybersecurity-related communication, and deterrence. The
central topic of our discussion will mainly centre on the current legal issues related to cybercrime
(Eboibi, 2020). The legal strategies employed to address cybercrime are based on
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
7
both national legislation and global agreements. The utilisation of domestic legislation to tackle
cybercrime is exemplified by the prominent legal case of United States v. Ulbricht, 2017.
The Budapest Convention, along with other international accords, is a crucial resource in the
battle against cybercrime around the world since it encourages the harmonisation of legal
frameworks and facilitates international cooperation.
The Budapest Convention, like the R. v.
McKinney decision, offers provisions for the criminal prosecution of those who engage in the
sexual exploitation of children via the Internet (Chang, 2019). Extradition, evidence collection, and
international investigations are all areas where the Convention aims to improve upon current
practices. The goal is to strengthen the ability of international legal systems to deter cybercrime.
Limits imposed by regulation are a practical strategy for combating cybercrime. The success of
goals depends on regular assessment and adjustment (De Paoli et al., 2020). The case of Grunin v.
Facebook, Inc, of the year 2014, exemplifies the complexities that might develop during cybercrime
investigations, especially when it comes to questions of jurisdiction (Eboibi, 2020).
Facebook has
filed lawsuits against individuals and businesses that have spread malware or engaged in
questionable commercial practices. The court's judgement emphasised the significance of protecting
the independence of the judicial system while enforcing legislation to combat global cybercrime.
The adoption of resilient cybersecurity protocols and pre-emptive tactics is imperative in
combatting cybercriminal activities. The case of R. v. Patel, 2017, highlights the significance of
implementing pre-emptive measures to alleviate the possible risks associated with cyber assaults.
The alleged offence involved the accused party's unauthorised acquisition of confidential medical
records (De Paoli et al., 2020). It is crucial for enterprises to implement comprehensive
cybersecurity measures, such as encryption, access controls, and periodic security assessments, in
order to minimise potential risks and safeguard sensitive information from malicious actors. The
existing legal structures and regulations that relate to cybercrime serve as the basis for managing
and supervising such behaviour (Hall et al., 2020).
The legal frameworks governing cybercrime at
national and international levels are shaped by domestic legislation and international agreements.
Ensuring the continued relevance and effectiveness of strategies aimed at preventing cybercrime in
the constantly evolving realm of this issue, requires continuous evaluation and improvement (De
Paoli et al., 2020). The effective execution of cybersecurity measures and preventative protocols is
of paramount importance in the proficient conviction of cyber offenders, the mitigation
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
8
of subsequent cyber offences, and the advancement of investigative methodologies such as digital
forensics and evidence collection (Hall et al., 2020). By implementing robust cybersecurity
protocols, employing modern investigative methodologies, and strengthening legislative
frameworks, society can effectively combat cybercrime and protect individuals, businesses, and
critical digital infrastructure from its harmful effects.
6.
Conclusion
In the contemporary digital landscape, safeguarding against cybercrime is of paramount
importance. To address the ubiquitous and ever-evolving nature of cybercrime, it is imperative that
the criminal justice system implement a proactive and all-encompassing approach without delay.
The study highlights the importance of a strong criminal justice system in maintaining legal order,
protecting essential human rights, and tackling cybercrime issues at a worldwide level. The issue of
cybercrime necessitates robust legislative frameworks and efficacious law enforcement measures.
Cybercrime is a phenomenon that affects various entities, including individuals, businesses, and the
wider public. The situation presents discernible financial, psychological, and emotional
ramifications. Research conducted on cybercrime has exposed the gravity of the matter and the
possible detrimental effects it could inflict upon various enterprises.
To effectively combat cybercrime, it is imperative that the criminal justice system undergoes
a constant process of evolution and modification of its procedures. The impediments to regulating
cybercrime effectively include the pace of technological progress, the ubiquity of cybercrime, and
the challenges associated with apprehending cybercriminals. The swift progression of technology
necessitates that law enforcement agencies possess the requisite competencies, approaches, and
assets to scrutinise, forestall, and detain cyber offenders. International collaboration is imperative in
the fight against transnational cybercrime, owing to concerns surrounding jurisdictional matters,
extradition protocols, and data privacy regulations. In order to accurately anticipate forthcoming
occurrences, it is imperative to revise legal structures and integrate global accords into domestic
statutes. Frequent evaluation and modification of the current regulatory structure are imperative to
ensure its alignment with the constantly evolving landscape of cybercrime. The effective
enforcement of cybercrime legislation necessitates
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
9
augmented financial resources for law enforcement agencies, an enhanced understanding of digital
forensics, and the fostering of collaboration between public and private entities.
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
10
References
Bello, M., & Griffiths, M. (2020). Routine Activity Theory and Cybercrime Investigation in
Nigeria: How Capable Are Law Enforcement Agencies? Rethinking Cybercrime, 3(2), 213
235. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-55841-3_11
Borwell, J., Jansen, J., & Stol, W. (2021). Comparing the victimization impact of cybercrime and
traditional crime. Journal of Digital Social Research, 3(3), 85–110.
https://doi.org/10.33621/jdsr.v3i3.66
Button, M., Shepherd, D., Blackbourn, D., Sugiura, L., Kapend, R., & Wang, V. (2022). Assessing
the seriousness of cybercrime: The case of computer misuse crime in the United Kingdom
and the victims’ perspective. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 0(0), 145–180.
https://doi.org/10.1177/17488958221128128
Chandra, A., & Snowe, M. J. (2020). A taxonomy of cybercrime: Theory and design. International
Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 38(3), 100–467.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.accinf.2020.100467
Chang, L. Y.-C. (2019). Criminological perspectives on cybercrime: risk, routine activity, and
cybercrime. Research Handbook on Transnational Crime, 3(2), 327–343.
https://www.elgaronline.com/abstract/edcoll/9781784719432/9781784719432.00030.xml
De Paoli, S.,
Johnstone, J., Coull, N., Ferguson, I., Sinclair, G., Tomkins, P., Brown, M., & Martin,
R. (2020). A Qualitative Exploratory Study of the Knowledge, Forensic, and Legal
Challenges from the Perspective of Police Cybercrime Specialists.
Policing: A Journal of
Policy and Practice, 15(2), 15–30. https://doi.org/10.1093/police/paaa027
Eboibi, F. E. (2020). Concerns of cyber criminality in South Africa, Ghana, Ethiopia and Nigeria:
rethinking cybercrime policy implementation and institutional accountability.
Commonwealth Law Bulletin, 3(2), 1–32. https://doi.org/10.1080/03050718.2020.1748075
ISBN: 978-93-5842-059-3
11
Hall, T., Sanders, B., Bah, M., King, O., & Wigley, E. (2020). Economic geographies of the illegal:
the multiscalar production of cybercrime.
Trends in Organized Crime, 3(2), 115–240.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12117-020-09392-w
Mohsin, K. (2020, August 14).
Global Perspective of Cyber Crimes and Related Laws.
Papers.ssrn.com. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3673938
Nwankwo, W., & Chiwuike Ukaoha, K. (2020).
Socio-Technical Perspectives On Cybersecurity:
Nigeria’s Cybercrime Legislation In Review.
https://www.edouniversity.edu.ng/oerrepository/articles/socio-
technical_perspectives_on_cybersecurity_nigerias_cybercrime_legislation_in_review.pdf
Rahman, Dr.
A. M., & Islam, S. (2021). Social-Costs Perspective Impacts of Cybercrime in World-
Economy, Country-Wise: Policy-Guidance under Piecemeal Approach. Information
Management and Business Review, 13(2(I)), 43–55.
https://doi.org/10.22610/imbr.v13i2(i).3229
Richards, N. U., & Eboibi, F. E. (2022). Cybercrime perspectives to the “ENDSARS” protest in
Nigeria. African Security Review, 3(3), 1–19.
https://doi.org/10.1080/10246029.2022.2141128
Suhartono, S. (2019).
Cyber Violence with Biosocial Perspective and The Role of Preventive
Legislative Mechanism. International Journal of Cyber Criminology, 15(2).https://cybercrimejournal.com/menuscript/index.php/cybercrimejournal/article/view/13
